Valero Energy Corporation · Energy
Survives a correction-sized 3-point cut to analyst growth.
Holds: at a 6.0% margin the price needs -3.5% 3y revenue growth against -0.6% consensus, a +6.8pt cushion versus a 0pt correction cut. Peak-cycle; AI-irrelevant.
Breaks if: Consensus 3y growth is cut by more than 6.8pt, or the through-cycle margin settles below 6.0%.. We re-check this against analyst estimates every evening.
10 years, at a 6% margin analysts expect
+0.7%/yr over 10 years once faded to terminal growth
points off 3-year analyst growth
25 published targets
Does the profit analysts build their margin on actually arrive as cash? Measured over the last 3 annual statements filed before this test. After stock-based pay, 156% of reported profit arrived as operating cash, so the analysts' margin stands.
How much of reported profit arrived as operating cash. Below 0.8× is a red flag.
Profit not backed by cash, as a share of assets, latest year. Above 10% is a red flag.
Staff paid in shares instead of cash, which flatters margins. Above 10% is a red flag.
Dilution of each share's claim on the business. Above 3% a year is a red flag.
Non-operating gains in the latest year. Above 25% is a red flag.
After capex. Shown for context: heavy investment is not bad earnings, so it is never solved under.
From the priced-in reconstruction of Nov 21, 2026. Its figures use that day's price and free-cash-flow margin, so they can differ from the stress test above.
At the price, the market sits 23% below the median published target ($435) and at the 8th percentile of 25 models, meaning the price pays only for a base-case of peak margins fading, not the diesel-crunch bull case 19 banks have published.
Are refining margins going to stay at 2026-crunch levels for longer than the endorsing models assume? That is a commodity pricing question — crack spreads and diesel prices — and no wired measurement (only attention series and segment revenue history) can observe margin or fuel pricing directly, so this driver cannot be settled with the available data.
What the price refuses to pay for, and the full reconstruction, on the VLO quote page →A stress test of whether this narrative is still paid for by analyst forecasts, not a forecast that the stock will rise. The price-implied growth on its own has not predicted returns in our testing, and this list (sealed Nov 21, 2026) has not been graded yet. Cut sizes are assumptions. Not investment advice. Back to all names