Zacks Investment Research
02 Nov 2026, 18:55 UTC · 1h ago
Impact · against what's priced in
Selective Insurance (SIGI) shows strong operational efficiency and outperformance, but the article highlights valuation premiums and slowing growth projections that limit further upside. The news is largely descriptive of recent performance rather than a catalyst for new price action.
No priced-in read yet
What the story claims
4 claims · scored −1 bearish … +1 bullish · 0 new · 4 priced in
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for Selective Insurance's 2026 earnings per share (EPS) indicates a 14.4% year-over-year increase.
Priced inanalysis of consensus estimates
So whatThis growth forecast contrasts with a significantly slower 4.1% EPS increase projected for 2027.
More positive than 76% of claims this week
Selective Insurance's price-to-book value of 1.80X is higher than the industry average of 1.49X.
Continue reading
5 related stories
The company's 15.6% ROE and 33.6% share gain demonstrate significant outperformance compared to the industry average ROE of 7.5%.
Read from the article alone
Scored by the NIS engine · methodology.
Top 1 mover · tap to explore
Priced inanalysis of valuation metrics
So whatThe 20.8% premium over industry average limits potential upside if ROE reverts toward the 7.5% industry mean.
More negative than 71% of claims this week
The consensus estimate for 2027 revenues indicates a 1.4% decline from the 2026 estimates of $5.43 billion.
Priced inanalysis of consensus estimates
So whatA revenue contraction in 2027 suggests that EPS growth will rely entirely on margin expansion or buybacks rather than top-line scale.
More negative than 71% of claims this week
The company's return on equity in the trailing 12 months was 15.6%, compared to the industry average of 7.5%.
Priced intrailing 12 month data
So whatGenerating returns more than double the industry average justifies the current P/B premium of 0.31X.
More positive than 48% of claims this week
Which stocks this story touches
More positive than 74% of ticker scores this week
The company has significantly outperformed its industry with improved underwriting profitability and strong ROE, despite some valuation concerns.
More positive than 45% of ticker scores this week
Mentioned as a peer with positive share gains over the past year.
More positive than 45% of ticker scores this week
Mentioned as a peer with modest share gains over the past year.
More positive than 45% of ticker scores this week
Mentioned as a peer that has seen share gains over the past year, though underperforming SIGI.
Free · No account
Get a free daily PDF briefing — the last 24 hours of news, with summaries and the market-impact score for each story, delivered an hour before the open.
We’ll watch
Pre-filled from this story — remove any you don’t want. Add more tickers & tags or fine-tune your watchlist anytime — every email has an edit link, no account needed.
Free forever · one email a day, max · unsubscribe in one click.How it works
Zacks Investment Research
4h ago
More positive than 33% of relationship scores this week
[mutual] Selective Insurance is compared to W.R. Berkley as a peer in the same industry.
More positive than 33% of relationship scores this week
[mutual] Selective Insurance is compared to NMI Holdings as a peer in the same industry.
+1.7%
Price agrees with the score
$100.50 vs $98.83 close before publication (Oct 30) · not market-adjusted
SIGI chart →
